Episcopal Church Presiding Bishop Katharine Jefferts Schori, along with other Christian and Jewish leaders, spoke to the US Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works earlier this week. She called for mandatory policies to halt climate change as a means of alleviating global poverty.
"Science has revealed that global warming is real, caused by human activities and is a threat not only to God's good creation but to all of humanity."
Jefferts Schori highlighted that global warming will have a negative impact on all of God's creation including those living in poverty, communities of color, and vulnerable communities in the U.S. and abroad. Jefferts Schori stated that "inaction now is the most costly course of action for those living in poverty" and noted that climate change legislation now will help protect those who would suffer most from global warming.
She is to be commended for focusing on the terrible scourge of global poverty but, if one considers the most pressing problems impinging on the world’s poor, climate change would be well down the list. Many initiatives would have a greater and more immediate impact than greenhouse gas emissions reductions, which would be very expensive and of indefinite effect.
For the cost of one year’s worth of Kyoto-mandated GHG reductions, we could supply clean drinking water for everyone in the world, thus saving two million lives and avoiding half a billion serious illnesses every year. That’s an immediate and lasting benefit.
Two billion of the world’s citizens have no electricity—no lighting and no refrigeration in their homes, places of work, hospitals and clinics. If those poorest of the poor had electricity, deaths would be averted, diseases diagnosed and treated, and the quality of their everyday lives improved. But if the overriding aim is to reduce GHG emissions, as +KJS advocates, then providing electricity to more of the world’s people would be discouraged.
As I said, it is good that Bishop Jefferts-Schori wants Western governments to help the poor. At the same time, I suggest that there are ways of helping which provide larger and long-lasting benefits with much greater certainty and far less expense than climate change policies.
The full text of Bishop Jefferts-Schori’s statement can be downloaded here (pdf).
Previous related posts: