Unlike most non-Canadian reporters, London Telegraph Beijing correspondent Richard Spencer takes note of the report by David Kilgour and David Matas on China’s trade in organs harvested from executed prisoners for transplant.
Outside Canada, no newspaper seems to have picked up the story, The Daily Telegraph included. There is a simple reason for this, of course. The uncontroversial, and verifiable bits of the report are old hat: we all know that foreigners are coming in significant numbers to China for transplants, and paying a lot of money to hospitals, and that nearly all such transplants are from executed prisoners.There is periodic outrage, and now the Chinese government promises something will be done about it. The bits that haven't been widely reported are based on testimony originally acquired from falun gong, the exercise and meditation group, or cult -depending on where you stand - which was banned in China by President Jiang Zemin in 1999 and pretty ruthlessly persecuted.
Claims by falun gong that their members have been specifically targeted by Chinese authorities for imprisonment, mass killing, and organ harvesting were widely investigated last year and found to be unproven. That angle is apparently based on hearsay evidence from a single reporter.
The most important points have previously been reported widely.
Yet the most recent report highlights things which are undoubtedly true and important, and increasingly admitted by the Chinese government itself:
- there is a substantial business in selling executed prisoners' organs
- many of the consumers are foreigners
- the organs are provided suspiciously quickly, indicating that either prematched prisoners are being executed to order or that there must at any time be a substantial pool to choose from
- much of the work is being done by military hospitals, or in civilian hospitals by military surgeons
- there is a total lack of transparency about everything to do with this issue: the numbers of people executed every year; their names; which have their organs removed; the documents in which they are supposed to have signed their agreements; the numbers of falun gong prisoners incarcerated; their names, and sentences.
Western governments should discourage companies from selling organ transplant-related drugs and supplies to China, and they should discourage citizens from traveling there for such procedures.
Previous related post: Albertans buying body parts in China: David Kilgour









Posts
