For years, economists have debated whether growth in labour productivity is attributable to production shifts from one plant to another or to productivity improvements within plants. If the latter theory is correct, then the competitive process arguably plays little part in productivity growth.
If the former theory is correct, on the other hand, the competitive process is of utmost importance. According to that view, productivity increases as firms turn over and output is shifted from one firm to another. The competitive process drives entry and exit of firms and shifts output shares toward firms that are more productive.
A new Statistics Canada study provides strong evidence in support of the view that competition accounts for the lion’s share of labour productivity growth.
The competitive process that shifts market share towards more productive firms accounted for about two thirds of aggregate labour productivity growth in Canadian manufacturing from 1989 to 1999, according to a new study that examines firm turnover and productivity growth.
. . .
The study finds that firms that gained market share tended to be more productive than firms that lost market share. The firms that entered the manufacturing sector by building new plants or acquiring new plants are more productive than those firms that exit by closing down plants or divesting existing plants. These results suggest that firm turnover should make a positive contribution to overall labour productivity growth of the manufacturing sector.
The study concludes that firm turnover associated with the competitive process accounted for about 70% of aggregate labour productivity growth in Canadian manufacturing. The remaining 30% was mostly attributable to productivity growth of the continuing firms that expanded their market share.
The study of Canadian manufacturing also found large-scale entry and exit of firms and sizeable shifts of market share among existing firms, contradicting the myths that large manufacturing firms stay large and that successful establishment of new businesses is rare.
The full study can be downloaded here (pdf); the executive summary is posted here.
Source:
Statistics Canada, 2006. " Study: Competition, firm turnover and productivity growth." The Daily, 25 September. Statistics Canada catalogue no. 11-001-XIE.http://www.statcan.ca/Daily/English/060925/d060925a.htm (accessed 25 September 2006).