Magic Statistics

“I accept no responsibility for statistics, which are a form of magic beyond my comprehension.” — Robertson Davies

May 21st, 2006 at 10:22 pm

Aislin on the Cartoon Jihad

unpublished Aislin cartoonOne of Canada’s premier editorial cartoonists draws under the name Aislin.  His real name is Terry Mosher (Aislin is the name of his eldest daughter), and he has drawn for Montreal newspapers since the late 1960s.

He gave a presentation to the Ottawa Press Club on 3 May, World Press Freedom Day.  The title was “Cartoon Wars” and the subject was the Danish Mohammed cartoons that occasioned riots across the Muslim world and protest marches and death threats across Europe.  The Association of Canadian Editorial Cartoonists has posted the entire presentation—including numerous political cartoons from around the world—at its website.

In Mr Mosher’s view, the whole controversy turned out badly for the cause of press freedom in the West.  Several cartoons about the heated and violent disagreements were published, but not one major Canadian newspaper, or indeed any mainstream English-speaking news outlet, actually printed any of the twelve cartoons.

This cartoon depicting the response of newspaper editors to the Cartoon Jihad was included in his presentation.  He says, “I didn’t even bother submitting this one to my editors”.

Read the whole thing.

Print This Post Print This Post
May 21st, 2006 at 8:33 pm

What has the UK Home Office done wrong now?

John Reid, UK Home SecretaryAre you sure you want to know?  The new Home Secretary, John Reid, has been on the job for barely two weeks, and there are already suggestions that he is being crushed by his department’s incompetence.  The former Home Secretary Charles Clarke was fired after revelations that thousands of foreign criminals were improperly permitted to remain in the UK after their release.  Now it has emerged that hundreds of violent criminals assigned to open prisons have vamoosed.  Records released for one such prison reveal that an average of almost two convicts have gone AWOL every week for the past three years.

Prison Service figures show that offenders have been escaping from Leyhill Open Prison, Glos [Gloucestershire], at the rate of almost two a week for three years.
 
It is one of 13 open prisons in England. The Home Office last night refused to give absconding rates for the others, but did not suggest they would be any less serious.

Robbery and burglary offenders were the main absconders. But 22 murderers and seven rapists have fled Leyhill since 1999.

David Laws, a local Liberal Democrat MP, requested the figures after being informed by area police that they have to devote considerable resources to crimes committed by Leyhill escapees.

More bad news had surfaced from the Home Office earlier this weekend.  The Criminal Records Bureau (CRB) has misclassified some 1500 innocent persons as criminals over the past two years, and almost 3000 since the CRB was established in 2002.

Opposition politicians seized on the disclosure that CRB errors led to ordinary people - from court ushers to students - being wrongly identified as pornographers, thieves and violent robbers.

Some people had been turned down for jobs or university places while others had to be fingerprinted at police stations to prove they were not criminals.

The Home Office described the errors as "regrettable" but refused to apologise.

The classification errors represent 0.03 percent of the nine million record checks carried out by the CRB.  A minuscule proportion indeed—but that’s small comfort to those whose applications for jobs or loans were rejected due to erroneous CRB information.

The Home Office’s excuse for the errors is made less compelling by the news that it was warned of faults a year ago.

Ministers were told a year ago that innocent lives were being ruined by errors in criminal records checks that labelled people as paedophiles and sex offenders.
. . .
The Times has learnt that an independent government- appointed watchdog called last year for improved procedures, including fingerprint checks, to avoid such blunders.

Can anything else go wrong?  Need you ask?

There was further embarrassment when it was confirmed that an immigration official had been suspended over allegations that he offered to help a teenage asylum seeker with her application in return for sex.

It was also disclosed that 232 foreign nationals arrested in counter terrorism operations were allowed to stay as asylum seekers - including 18 who applied for refugee status only after their arrest.
. . .
The Home Office also revealed that the Immigration and Nationality Directorate spent £21 million on "consultancy support" in 2005-06.

The figure was disclosed after the IND, with the help of a firm of consultants, produced a bizarre report containing cartoons, graffiti and meaningless squiggles.

That last complaint is overly critical, I think.  In my experience, government consultants usually churn out bizarre and meaningless reports.  Cartoons would be an improvement over some that I’ve seen (although I admit graffiti would be a new one for me).

One almost feels sorry for Mr Reid.

Print This Post Print This Post
May 21st, 2006 at 12:58 pm

Harry Lehotsky testifies

Inner-city Winnipeg pastor and social activist Rev Harry Lehotsky reflects on the news that he has inoperable cancer.  Last Monday Harry was told that he has only a few months to live.

How does a Christian man with a wife and children deal with the realisation that he is apparently going to die prematurely?  It would, I would think, be natural for Harry to suppose that an effective public advocate for the poor and unfortunate—i.e., someone like him—should be spared a painful, early death.  Based on decades of work in which he has repeatedly put the needs of others ahead of his own, he might be justified in concluding that he and his family deserve better.  Instead, however, he reacts with grace, humility, and thankfulness for what God has given.

My life is no more or less important than those multitudes of fathers, mothers, sisters, brothers, lovers and partners that have received similar news. They too were loved and needed by those around them.

My life and efforts have been quite public, especially some of my achievements, advocacy, risks and sacrifices. But the public nature of my work makes me no more important than the many who struggle in relative silence, faithful to every one of their responsibilities and loved ones.

Is he mad at God?  Does he feel that the Almighty has dealt unfairly with him?  No: he is humbled by the undeserved goodness he has received from our Lord’s hand.

People have asked whether I'm mad at God.

If I was, I'm sure He could handle it. It wouldn't be the first time a loving parent dealt graciously with the confusion of an angry child.

But as I searched my jumbled emotions, I honestly couldn't detect a shred of anger against God. How could I be angry with the One who has given me more than I ever asked or imagined? I've received immeasurably more than I deserved.

During my teens, there was a period in which I spurned the love and example of my family. My random acts of stupidity and cruelty hurt many people around me. At one point, my pursuit of delusions resulted in an overdose. Fading fast, my "friends" were afraid of being stuck with a dead body, so they rolled me out of the car and left me by the curb.

I was rescued, ironically by one of the police officers I used to call a "pig." In hospital, I promised God the rest of my life if he got me through that day. He did, and I've had 32 years of a second chance to do better.

But it wasn't just about doing better. I've experienced a forgiveness beyond anything I deserved, and opportunities and hope I could never have manipulated for myself. All this from the hands of my loving Saviour. How could I be angry with the One who has given so much?

I know Rev Harry only through his writings and news reports of his activities, but based on that, he appears as a great man of God and a saint for our time.  What he writes today is nothing less than inspirational.  Read the whole thing.

A prayer of American Baptist minister and theologian Walter Rauschenbusch, whose work inspired Harry in his:

O God, grant us a vision of this city, fair as it might be: a city of justice, where none shall prey upon the other; a city of plenty, where vice and poverty shall cease to fester; a city of brotherhood, where success is founded on service; and honor shall be given to nobleness alone; a city of peace, where order shall not rest on force, but on the love of all for each and all.

Previous related post: Rev Harry Lehotsky diagnosed with terminal cancer.

Print This Post Print This Post
May 21st, 2006 at 6:00 am

The Fifth Sunday After Easter

The collect for today, The Fifth Sunday After Easter, from the 1662 Book of Common Prayer:

O Lord, from whom all good things do come; Grant to us thy humble servants, that by thy holy inspiration we may think those things that be good, and by thy merciful guiding may perform the same; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

The Epistle: St James 1:22-27
The Gospel: St John 16:23-33

Print This Post Print This Post
|