Guardian columnist Theo Hobson ponders the reasons for the popularity of the Da Vinci Code (DVC). Is it just that whopping conspiracy theories are in vogue, especially when presented as a fast-paced thriller? That’s important, but he discerns more going on here.
The Da Vinci Code phenomenon is a sign of spiritual cowardice. Those who are fascinated by the conspiracy theory lack the courage either to accept Christianity in some form or to reject it entirely. So they inhabit a strange limbo of cultic fascination, parasitic on the religion it claims to unmask. They do not exactly believe Dan Brown's theory (no more than he does himself), but they flirt with believing it. Maybe it was like this, they say. Maybe we have not been told the truth about the real Jesus. Maybe he married Mary Magdalene and started a royal bloodline. That would really put the cat among the clerical pigeons! No wonder the churches have always denied the possibility so defensively.
It is a cowardly and inauthentic response to religion, a failure to be serious about what is serious. Religion is a serious, grown-up business. It involves a claim to truth that must either be accepted or rejected. Either you believe some form of Christianity to be the meaning of life or you reject it in all its forms. In the latter case, you will either prefer another religion or you will dismiss every religion as erroneous. Both options are intellectually respectable. What is not intellectually respectable is the conspiracy theorist's attempt to duck the question of the truth or falsity of Christianity, by wondering whether another story might be concealed within the conventional one.
To focus, as the DVC apologist is wont, on the bare bones of the story—did Jesus die and rise again, or did he get married and raise a family—is still to miss the point. Christianity is a religion, offering reconciliation with God and eternity with Christ. DVC, having only minimal theological content, barely rises to the level of heresy—and a singularly cynical one at that. What does it offer beyond a few hours entertainment? (Well, OK, a few devotees have turned it into years of entertainment by making pilgrimages to the sites in the book.) Certainly nothing of eternal significance.
The DVC phenomenon tries to ride the coattails of Protestantism in particular, which was born accusing Catholicism of covering up the unvarnished gospel of Jesus. But here, too, DVC, because it fails to offer a genuine alternative account of Christianity, must be viewed as a parasitic and fundamentally unserious distortion of true religion.
via Christianity Today Weblog.
Previous related posts:









Posts
