Magic Statistics

"I accept no responsibility for statistics, which are a form of magic beyond my comprehension." — Robertson Davies

April 18th, 2006 at 9:55 pm

Low-income countries are aging, too

Much attention has been given to aging populations in developed countries, but nations in virtually every region of the globe have to deal with similar demographic trends.  The only parts of the world not experiencing below-replacement fertility are sub-Saharan Africa and most of the Arab Muslim world.  Everywhere else—East Asia, South Asia, the Middle East, Eastern Europe, and Latin America—birth rates are below replacement, and apparently set to decline further.

When birth rates fall below replacement level, within a decade or two, a significantly larger proportion of the population will become elderly.  If birth rates do not increase above replacement, total population generally begins to decline within about a generation.

Welfare systems in wealthier nations face costly adjustments to aging populations.  Income support and medical care programs will soon be stretched to the limit.  Difficult changes will have to be implemented to keep the programs afloat.  Poorer nations, however, even now do not have social safety net programs that developed nations do.  Grim times are ahead as their populations age.

The burdens of pronounced population aging . . . are unlikely to be born as easily by countries still poor as by countries already rich. Simply stated, societies and governments have fewer options for dealing with the problems imposed by population aging when income levels are low — and the options available are distinctly less attractive than they would be if income levels were higher.

Nicholas Eberstadt has written a lengthy paper on the demographic outlook for three populous low-income countries: China, Russia, and India.  He does not paint a pretty picture.

China faces an extremely rapidly aging population within the next twenty years, mostly because of the effectiveness of its coercively enforced one-child-per-family policy.  By 2025, China is projected to have less than 20% of the earth’s population but more than 25% of its elderly (aged 65 or over).  Mr Eberstadt argues that aging trends will not be spread evenly throughout the country, but concentrated in poorer areas.

Senior citizens will not be taken care of by China’s public pension system, which already is an unsustainable financial mess.  People will try to fall back on the traditional support system: the family.  But the one-child policy has crippled the Chinese family’s ability to take care of the aged.  There simply are not enough children to take care of the all the elderly.  So, China’s elderly can look forward to extending their working lives to support themselves.  In rural areas, older workers tend to be poorly educated farm labourers performing low-paying but physically arduous tasks.  This produces what Mr Eberstadt calls the “triple bind” of China’s aging problem.

In the years ahead, China’s senior citizens are not only likely to face real and perhaps mounting pressures to support themselves through paid labor, and not only likely to find that their employment opportunities are principally in low-paying, physically demanding jobs; they are also likely to be less healthy and more fragile than counterparts in other countries where the physical demands of employment are much less forbidding for the elderly and nonelderly alike.

A large population of poverty-stricken and infirm aged could well emerge as China’s major social problem within a few decades.

Russia and India will also have to deal with rapidly increasing numbers of elderly without the wealth available to Western nations confronted with similar demographic trends.

Read the whole thing.

via Arts & Letters Daily.

Previous related posts:

Print This Post Print This Post
April 18th, 2006 at 7:52 pm

We’ll regulate them back into the Middle Ages

New European Union clean-water regulations require that half the arable farmland in the east of England must be returned to grass within six years, or else the country will face huge fines for pollution.

Researchers have concluded that the land must go back to what it was in the Middle Ages if new EU rules on reducing nitrate pollution in water are not to be breached.

The stark choice in the prairies of East Anglia – famous for their wool 500 years ago – is between arable crops and good water quality, according to the Agricultural Development and Advisory Service (Adas), a privatised former Government agency.
. . .
Europe has set a legislative timetable under the Water Framework Directive for returning all drinking water supplies and water in rivers, ponds and lakes to "good" water quality by 2015. At present 95 per cent of all water bodies in England and Wales would fail the standard set out in the directive.

British soil scientist Prof Roger Sylvester-Bradley is critical of the EU regulations.

"I believe that we should be looking at smart solutions and not throwing out the baby will the bath water and losing British agriculture."

Daniel Webster famously said, “An unlimited power to tax involves, necessarily, the power to destroy.”  If Webster had only foreseen the EU, he might have said the same of the power to regulate.

Print This Post Print This Post
April 18th, 2006 at 7:09 pm

We have a right to be unaccountable

Why am I not surprised?  An Alberta aboriginal leader says the proposed Federal Accountability Act would infringe on aboriginal rights.  The act is designed to, among other goals, empower the Auditor General to inspect the financial records of First Nation governments receiving federal funding.

Rose Loubcan, chief of the Driftpile nation in northern Alberta, says the act, if passed as written, interferes with their right to self-government.

"We have a yearly audit by a reputable firm," Laboucan said. "With my community, we go through [the audit] line by line … with our band members. We have a public general meeting on the audit, so we're very accountable."

(CBC apparently doesn't know how to spell the chief's name, but "Laboucan" is the correct spelling.)  Ms Laboucan misses the point of the act.  Its purpose is to assure Canadian taxpayers that their funds are spent responsibly and effectively.  Discussing an audit at a First Nation's Annual General Meeting does not fulfill that goal.

Here's someone who knows what this is all about.

But Tanis Fiss, director of the Centre for Aboriginal Policy Change – a branch of the Canadian Taxpayers' Federation – in Calgary, disagrees. She says taxpayers deserve the right to know where the $8 billion spent annually on aboriginal affairs is going

"As long as a community receives tax dollars, taxpayers deserve to know how that money is spent, where it's spent, whether or not they're getting value for their money," Fiss said.

Bottom line, Ms Laboucan: If you stop accepting taxpayers' money, then you won't be accountable for how you spend it.

via Dust My Broom.

Print This Post Print This Post
April 18th, 2006 at 6:45 pm

Christian conversions present “grave threat to Hindu society”

Lal Krishna Advani, former Deputy Prime Minister of India, goes apoplectic over successful Christian evangelism in his country.  AsiaNews reports:

“We strongly condemn the campaign of [Christian] proselytisation [sic] which poses a grave threat to Hindu society. We demand stern action against those who indulge in such activities,” Advani said.
. . .
“It is bad enough that religious conversions are conducted in a systematic manner through inducements and coercions [sic]. But such activities are more ominous when they are facilitated by foreign funded organisations, ostensibly under the garb of social service for poor and under-privileged families. We will raise our voice strongly in favour of a national as well as state-level legislation prohibiting religious conversions through inducements or coercion,” Advani added.

Christian leaders in India reject all charges as without basis in fact.

“When he was Union home minister, Mr Advani made similar allegations,” said All Indian Catholic Union Chairman John Dayal. “I challenged him to produce a white paper [presenting evidence] and as expected he failed to do so,” Mr Dayal told AsiaNews.

“I challenge him once again to [. . . present evidence] about forcible conversions. In Rajasthan for instance, the total population is well over 60 million, and the Christian population is just about 86,000. This is one tenth of one per cent. Forcible conversions? Ridiculous.”

Fr Babu Joseph, spokesman for the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of India, points out that the real threat to Indian society comes from widespread poverty, unemployment, and poor education.  Mr Advani should direct his indignation toward those problems.

Christian leaders fear that Mr Advani's forcefully expressed accusations could incite attacks on Christians by the Hindu extremist youth group Bajrang Dal, which has been implicated in violence in the past.  As John at Verum Serum says, Mr Advani's tirade amounts to "Hitlerian demagoguery".

Another story in today's AsiaNews indicates that Christian evangelism can get you arrested in India.  No coercion in sight here:

Indian police have arrested two Christian women in Madhaya Pradesh, accusing them of “attempting to convert people by distributing pamphlets on the Bible”. The women were arrested on Friday 14 April, Good Friday.

Mariamma Mathew, 36, and B. Godwil, 65, were arrested after a person, who remained anonymous, reported them for “explaining to people how they can have a peaceful life following Bible teachings”.

In India, explaining that following biblical teaching brings peace is a criminal offence.  How pathetic is that?  Some people over there must be very afraid of the Gospel.  Christian leaders say there have been many similar arrests in recent years.

This would be a good time to pray for the two women.

Print This Post Print This Post
April 18th, 2006 at 6:00 am

Tuesday in Easter-Week

The collect for today, Tuesday in Easter Week, from the 1662 Book of Common Prayer:

Almighty God, who through thine only-begotten Son Jesus Christ hast overcome death, and opened unto us the gate of everlasting life; We humbly beseech thee, that, as by thy special grace preventing us thou dost put into our minds good desires, so by thy continual help we may bring the same to good effect; through Jesus Christ our Lord, who liveth and reigneth with thee and the Holy Ghost, ever one God, world without end. Amen.

For the Epistle: Acts 13:26-41
The Gospel: St Luke 24:36-48

Print This Post Print This Post
|